Evaluator Rubric
Use this rubric after implementation and before final acceptance.
| Category | Question | Score (0-2) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Correctness | Does the implemented behavior match the requested feature? | ||
| Verification | Did the required checks actually run, with evidence? | ||
| Scope discipline | Did the session stay inside the chosen feature scope? | ||
| Reliability | Does the result survive restart or rerun without repair? | ||
| Maintainability | Is the code and documentation clear enough for the next session? | ||
| Handoff readiness | Can a fresh session continue work from repo artifacts only? |
Verdict
- Accept
- Revise
- Block
Required Follow-Up
- Missing evidence:
- Required fixes:
- Next review trigger: