Skip to content

Evaluator Rubric

Use this rubric after implementation and before final acceptance.

CategoryQuestionScore (0-2)Notes
CorrectnessDoes the implemented behavior match the requested feature?
VerificationDid the required checks actually run, with evidence?
Scope disciplineDid the session stay inside the chosen feature scope?
ReliabilityDoes the result survive restart or rerun without repair?
MaintainabilityIs the code and documentation clear enough for the next session?
Handoff readinessCan a fresh session continue work from repo artifacts only?

Verdict

  • Accept
  • Revise
  • Block

Required Follow-Up

  • Missing evidence:
  • Required fixes:
  • Next review trigger: